What’s the best way to test for colon cancer?

Written by: Mr David McArthur
Published:
Edited by: Cal Murphy

Colorectal cancer, also known as colon cancer or bowel cancer, can be a worrying prospect, especially as we get older. Regular screening is important, especially for those over the age of 60. But how do we test for colorectal cancer? Expert colorectal surgeon Mr David McArthur explains.

Symptoms

The most appropriate investigation depends on the symptoms the patient presents with, whilst taking into account other patient-related factors such as age and other co-morbidities.

Symptoms of colorectal cancer include:

  • Rectal bleeding
  • A change in bowel habit
  • Abdominal pain or bloating
  • Weight loss
  • Anaemia

However, colorectal cancer may be asymptomatic and is only detected as part of a screening process.

 

Colonoscopy

The gold standard investigation is colonoscopy. Patients take an oral bowel prep to cleanse the colon prior to the test, which is usually performed using light sedation or entonox (gas and air). The procedure involves passing a flexible telescope through the anal canal and the entire colon to where it transitions into the small bowel, allowing direct visualisation of the bowel lining.

It is possible to take biopsy specimens of abnormalities seen, in addition to allowing therapeutic options, such as the removal of polyps (berry-like growths in the bowel lining). If cancer is detected, it is also possible to tattoo the site in the colon to facilitate laparoscopic (keyhole) surgery for the treatment of the condition. 

The test usually takes 15-20 minutes to complete and is performed as a day-case. It is generally regarded as a safe test, with small risks of bleeding if samples are taken, pain, and a very small risk of perforation of the bowel. It has the highest sensitivity for detecting lesions within the bowel.

 

Flexible sigmoidoscopy

An alternative to colonoscopy, if patients present with symptoms suggestive of a problem closer to the anal canal (e.g. bright red rectal bleeding), is a limited endoscopic examination of the lower bowel called flexible sigmoidoscopy. For this test, an enema is usually administered to the patient to clear the left side of the colon. Then, the procedure is performed in the same way as colonoscopy, although the entire colon is not examined.

Occasionally, if flexible sigmoidoscopy reveals a polyp, they will need to return on another occasion to have a full colonoscopy to exclude polyps in the rest of the colon. The risks of the procedure are similar to colonoscopy.

 

CT scan

Another modality to investigate the bowel involves the use of CT scanning, in the form of a CT virtual colonoscopy. For this test, patients are given bowel preparation, similar to that for colonoscopy.

The patient lies in the CT scanner in two different positions, whilst gas (carbon dioxide) is inserted into the lower bowel through a narrow tube in the anal canal to distend the colon. Computer reformatting of the scan allows a radiologist to effectively fly though the colon and visualise any growths or abnormalities. The sensitivity is almost as high as that of visual colonoscopy, although small or flat polyps can be missed.

There is also the disadvantage that if there are abnormalities detected, patients often have to subsequently undergo a visual colonoscopy (e.g. to remove a polyp or biopsy a potentially cancerous growth).

CT virtual colonoscopy is generally less onerous for patients to go through. It is often used for older patients, and in those whose symptoms might have an alternative abdominal cause, whereby the CT scan examines not only the bowel, but also the rest of the abdominal structures.

 

Blood tests

Some GPs will perform blood tests on patients who present with bowel-related symptoms. CEA (carcinoembryonic antigen) is sometimes elevated in patients who have bowel cancer, and occasionally, patients will be referred who have had a CEA test that showed above-normal levels.

Unfortunately, it is not a very sensitive screening test and can be raised in other circumstances, such as in patients who smoke. It is generally reserved for monitoring patients after they have undergone treatment for bowel cancer.

Other blood tests that are non-specific, but can point to a potential problem in the bowel, include a low haemoglobin level (anaemia), associated with reduced iron levels, which can result from bowel cancer-related bleeding very slowly over a period of time into the bowel, which has gone unnoticed by the patient.

 

Screening with faecal tests

Screening for colorectal cancer aims to detect the condition, as well as pre-cancerous bowel polyps, before symptoms develop – if the disease is caught earlier, the outcome is likely to be better. Currently, in the UK, screening applies to patients between the ages of 60-74, although the age range is due to be reduced to include younger patients.

At present, patients are sent a home test kit every two years called a faecal occult blood test (FOBT). The investigation involves testing a faecal sample for the detection of blood. A positive test results in patients being invited for a colonoscopy. FOBT, although useful in this context, is unfortunately not very sensitive or specific, meaning it will not detect everyone with cancer or polyps, and it will result in a positive test for a proportion of patients who have no underlying condition.

A newer screening test called FIT (faecal immunochemical test) is currently being trialled and rolled out across the UK. It has advantages in terms of its acceptability to patients, and improved sensitivity and specificity over FOBT.

 

Visit Mr McArthur’s Top Doctors profile to book an appointment.

By Mr David McArthur
Colorectal surgery

Mr David Ross McArthur is an experienced consultant colorectal, general and laparoscopic surgeon based in Birmingham. Mr McArthur has a specialist interest in minimally-invasive techniques for the management of colorectal and general surgical conditions, including laparoscopy (keyhole surgery) to treat hernias and all colorectal conditions (cancer and inflammatory bowel disease), and novel techniques to treat haemorrhoids (Rafaelo, THD, eXroid). In addition, Mr McArthur offers treatment for a full range of benign anorectal conditions, including piles, anal fissure, anal fistula and pilonidal sinus, and is a fully trained, JAG-accredited colonoscopist, offering both diagnostic and therapeutic colonoscopy.

Mr McArthur qualified from the University of Birmingham with honours in surgery. He was awarded an MD by the University of Warwick for his research into the pathogenesis of colorectal cancer and later completed a fellowship in laparoscopic colorectal surgery at Leeds, where he developed a specialist interest in the management of patients with advanced and recurrent rectal cancer. In 2011, Mr McArthur was appointed Consultant General and Colorectal Surgeon at Heart of England NHS Foundation Trust, and in 2018 continued in this role at University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Trust. At the Trust, he has played a key role in furthering the provision of laparoscopic colorectal surgery and setting up a service for patients with locally advanced and recurrent rectal cancer.

Throughout his career Mr McArthur has maintained a key interest in teaching, first as a lecturer in anatomy at the University of Birmingham, and more recently as course director for the Royal College of Surgeons' "Strategies in Emergency General Surgery", and the ACPGBI "M42 Coloproctology for Junior Surgical Trainee" courses. He has published widely on a variety of colorectal and general surgical conditions and has presented at numerous international and national meetings. He has sat on the Council of the Association of Coloproctology of Great Britain and Ireland from 2016-2019.

View Profile

Overall assessment of their patients


This website uses its own and third-party cookies to collect information in order to improve our services, to show you advertising related to your preferences, as well as to analyse your browsing habits..