Should I have laser eye or lens replacement surgery?

Written by: Mr Scott Robbie
Published:
Edited by: Laura Burgess

What is refractive surgery?

Refractive surgery refers to a group of procedures that are designed to improve or correct vision for patients who are glasses dependent. Those patients may be short-sighted, long-sighted or have astigmatism, which is where the shape of the front of the eye (the cornea) is a little irregular in such a way that they need some correction in their glasses to improve the vision. It also incorporates a group of patients who may find that they are getting a blurred vision as they get older and start to need reading glasses.



Refractive surgery is generally regarded as being something where you operate on the cornea and most people have heard of LASIK, which is very commonly performed on patients who are younger and want to get rid of their glasses.

LASIK is one procedure of a great many and in fact, refractive procedures can involve surgery to the cornea and also inside the eye. In recent years, the advance of technology such as intraocular lenses, which allows different degrees of focus, have come on the scene and really expanded the range of options available to those sorts of patients. But for younger patients who may have very high glasses prescriptions, there are other options where one might, for example, put a lens inside the eye in addition to their natural lens so that they maintain accommodation and the ability to focus the near and distance.

Laser eye surgery

Laser eye surgery involves reshaping the cornea. The cornea is the clear window at the front of the eye that actually does most of the focusing power of the eye. For younger patients who are maybe short-sighted or long-sighted, laser eye surgery is used to reshape the cornea and refocus the light at the back of the eye. That’s being done for a number of years now and is generally a very safe procedure and very effective for that category of patients. It is also used in older patients, but the downside is that as we get older, the eye changes. So the ability to focus for near-sight diminishes in our forties and fifties. Laser eye surgery that has been conductive when you were younger does not necessarily provide that near vision that you need when you are older.

Lens replacement surgery

The alternative is to either reshape the cornea, to refocus the light for near for one eye or it may involve going inside the eye to remove the lens that is no longer able to provide that near vision and replacing it with a clear plastic lens that maybe will give you a degree of what we call multifocality. That means that the lens will provide some distance vision, some intermediate vision, for maybe looking at your computer, and maybe some near vision so that you can read without your glasses. Of course, going inside the eye does involve a degree of risk but with modern cataract surgery techniques and an experienced surgeon, the risks to the eye are extremely low.

Should I have laser eye or lens replacement surgery?

In short, laser eye surgery can be used at any age, but generally is more effective and simpler to perform in patients who are younger where the results of surgery are such that they will still retain this ability to accommodate for near that is lost as we get older. And as we get older, maybe it's better to move to a procedure where we can remove the lens that is no longer able to provide that near vision and replace it with the lens to give you a degree of flexibility in terms of achieving glasses independence.

How to choose an ophthalmologist for eye surgery

Every eye is different and every patient is different. Their needs are different. With the huge array of options available to patients, now, it’s no wonder that the business of trying to choose a solution for you is often very fraught and confusing. I suggest that you find a surgeon that you trust and that you are happy with and that has the experience to manage and guide you through the process of coming to a solution to your eye problem. They also need a skill set that permits them to handle any complications that might occur as a result of the surgery because most complications, if handled effectively and corrected correctly, can result in a good outcome.

By Mr Scott Robbie
Ophthalmology

Mr Scott Robbie is a renowned consultant ophthalmologist at Guy’s and St. Thomas’ Hospitals specialising in cornea, cataract, external diseases and refractive surgery. He has over 15 years’ experience in ophthalmology with over 3000 cataract surgeries performed.

Mr Robbie trained at Moorfields Eye Hospital NHS Foundation Trust where he completed two years of advanced corneal surgical training and a further two years as a consultant in cornea, cataract and external diseases before joining the team at Guy’s and St. Thomas’ in 2017. He obtained further experience as a visiting consultant at University of Iowa Hospitals in the United States in 2015. Mr Robbie also  has a PhD in Genetics, undertaken at the world-renowned UCL Institute of Ophthalmology, where he was involved in the first gene therapy trial for an eye condition and engaged in collaborations with GlaxoSmithKline and the University of Bristol, amongst others.

As a prestigious National Institute for Health Research Clinical Lecturer at Moorfields, he obtained funding to develop a translational project examining the use of gene therapy viral vectors to treat corneal neovascularisation and to this day, he continues to work on this as a research associate at University College London. He has more than 30 peer-reviewed publications to his name. 

One of the highlights of Mr Robbie's career is that he was selected as one of the eye surgeons responsible for providing care to athletes in the Athlete’s Village at the London 2012 Olympics and Paralympics. He maintains a broad research interest that encompasses novel therapeutics and intraocular lens technologies, most recently lens technology developed to improve visual outcomes in patients with macular disease undergoing cataract surgery.

His wealth of expertise and dedication to the field of ophthalmology has lead him to be a key figure in the teaching and training of many junior doctors and medical students. He regularly trains other surgeons in cataract and corneal surgery in the NHS.

View Profile

Overall assessment of their patients


This website uses its own and third-party cookies to collect information in order to improve our services, to show you advertising related to your preferences, as well as to analyse your browsing habits..